FA20 Head Gasket Replacement: A Complete Guide
Share
The head gasket seals the combustion chamber and keeps oil and coolant in their own passages. When it fails, fluids mix, compression escapes, and a repair that was manageable becomes an engine rebuild if you keep driving. Catching it early is the whole game.
The engine is also already apart when this job happens. That makes it the right time to inspect the heads properly and address anything else the teardown exposes, instead of paying the same labor twice.
How to Tell if Your FA20 Head Gasket Is Blown
Coolant System Warning Signs
Coolant loss with no puddle and no visible leak is the first sign. The coolant is going somewhere — often into the combustion chamber, where it burns off as sweet-smelling white smoke from the exhaust, especially on startup.
The other sign is oil in the cooling system: a sludgy, oily film inside the radiator or on the radiator cap. Pressurized oil is being forced into the coolant passages through the breach. A cooling system contaminated with oil cannot do its job, and overheating follows.
Checking Your Oil for Contamination
Coolant in the oil shows as milky, frothy oil on the dipstick — the chocolate milkshake look. Coolant destroys oil's ability to lubricate bearings and camshafts. Running the engine in that state does severe internal damage quickly.
Check for external leaks too. A gasket that fails on an outer edge weeps coolant from the seam between the head and the block. Dried, crusty coolant stains — often green or blue — on the side of the engine mean the seal is compromised.
Drops in Engine Performance
The gasket seals combustion pressure. When it fails between two cylinders, or between a cylinder and a coolant passage, compression is lost. The results are a drop in power, a rough and shaky idle, misfires, a check engine light, and hard starting. A tune cannot fix a mechanical fault. The gasket gets fixed first.
Running Hot
If the temperature gauge climbs into the red, pull over and shut the engine off. Driving an overheating engine can warp the heads or seize the engine entirely.
A failing gasket overheats an engine two ways. It forces hot combustion gases into the cooling system, creating air pockets and pushing coolant out of the overflow, which overwhelms the radiator. Or a coolant leak lowers the fluid level until the temperature spikes.
What Causes FA20 Head Gasket Failure
Overheating Is the Number One Culprit
Excessive heat is the leading cause. When temperature goes past the normal operating range, the aluminum cylinder heads expand and warp. The heads and the block expand at different rates, and that movement crushes and destroys the gasket's seal.
That is why the cooling system matters so much, especially on a modified FA20. A stuck thermostat, a coolant leak, or a failing water pump can become major engine damage in a short distance.
Design vs. Simple Wear and Tear
No gasket lasts forever. Over thousands of miles it endures countless heat cycles and contains combustion pressure every cycle. The material eventually breaks down.
Added power accelerates the process. More boost means more pressure and more heat in the cylinders, and the factory gasket was designed for stock levels. That is why owners who are already inside the engine often fit a stronger multi-layer steel (MLS) gasket as a preventive upgrade.
The FA20 vs. Older EJ Engines
Subaru's head gasket reputation comes largely from older, naturally aspirated EJ-series engines built before 2012. Those engines had known weaknesses that Subaru later corrected with stronger MLS gaskets — the same type used in their turbo engines. The FA20 is a different, more modern design and does not share those inherent vulnerabilities. Any engine can fail a gasket under enough stress. The FA20 is not predisposed to it.
Timing Chain vs. Timing Belt
The FA20 uses a timing chain, designed to last the life of the engine. Many older 2.5L EJ engines used a timing belt that required replacement every 60,000 to 100,000 miles — a costly, labor-intensive service the FA20 does not need.
Neglect
Skipping coolant flushes, using the wrong coolant, running oil low, or stretching oil change intervals all add thermal stress and corrosion. Check fluid levels, fix small leaks before they grow, and keep the service schedule. Modified cars need more care, not less — see the FA20 reliability mods guide.
Everything You Need for an FA20 Head Gasket Job
Essential Tools
- A high-quality torque wrench. Head bolts go to exact specification; this prevents leaks and warpage.
- A comprehensive socket set, including a 14mm 12-point socket for the head bolts, plus standard 10mm and 12mm sockets.
- A good set of wrenches for the remaining fasteners.
- A gasket scraper for the block and head surfaces.
- A large coolant drain pan.
Gaskets and Seals
This is not the place to cut corners. A leaking gasket means doing the job again. Use a complete, high-quality kit — a genuine Subaru OEM gasket and seal kit restores factory function, and a full kit ensures every single-use seal and gasket disturbed during disassembly gets replaced.
Aftermarket Gasket Options, Thickness, and Materials
For a modified engine, a performance MLS gasket is built for higher cylinder pressures and heat than an OEM gasket designed for stock power. Thickness is a real choice: options include 0.78mm, 1.10mm, and 1.50mm. Thickness changes the space above the piston at top-dead-center, which changes the compression ratio — a thinner gasket raises it, a thicker gasket lowers it, which can suit a high-boost build or compensate for material removed when the block or heads were machined.
Most performance gaskets are multiple layers of high-grade stainless steel, such as AISI 304, for strength and corrosion resistance. The layers are embossed and coated to seal on imperfect surfaces, and the design reinforces the areas most prone to failure, particularly around the combustion chamber.
Have fresh engine oil and coolant on hand before disassembly starts. Both systems get drained completely during the job, and the refill uses new, clean fluids of the correct type and amount.
Should You Upgrade While You're In There?
With the engine disassembled, added labor for related work is small. The sensible candidates are upgraded head studs for greater clamping force, a radiator upgrade for cooling efficiency, performance camshafts, and less restrictive exhaust headers or a modified airbox. Crawford's WRX upgrades collection covers the platform.
For the heads themselves, this is the decision point. Crawford sells built and BTO — Better Than Original — head packages, and offers machine shop services including a 5-angle valve job. If the heads are off, warped, or cracked, a package built for the power level beats returning a compromised head to service.
How to Replace an FA20 Head Gasket: Step by Step
Step 1: Engine Prep and Teardown
Drain the engine oil and coolant first. Disconnect the battery. Label every hose, connector, and bolt removed, and take photos along the way — reassembly will thank you. Clear a path to the heads by removing the intake manifold, exhaust components, and accessories.
Step 2: Pulling and Inspecting the Heads
Disconnect the main wiring harness and ECU connections. Pull the radiator and air intake for working space. Loosen the head bolts in the correct sequence — typically from the outside in — to avoid warping the head, then lift the heads off the block.
Inspect now. Check the heads for cracks, and check for warpage with a straight edge and feeler gauge. Any imperfection can compromise the new gasket's seal.
Step 3: Prepping the Mating Surfaces
Both the block deck and the head surfaces must be perfectly clean. Leftover debris, oil, or old gasket material creates a leak path. Remove old material gently with a plastic scraper or a razor blade held at a low angle. Do not use abrasive pads or tools that can gouge the soft aluminum. Finish with brake cleaner or acetone on a lint-free cloth until the surfaces are spotless, then check both surfaces for warpage with a precision straightedge and feeler gauge. Anything beyond factory tolerance gets machined before the job proceeds.
Step 4: Installing the New Gasket and Reassembling
Check the gasket's orientation — most are marked "UP" or carry a pattern that must align with the block's oil and coolant passages. Set it over the dowel pins on the block, reinstall the heads, and use new head bolts: the old ones are often torque-to-yield and stretch during installation. Follow the manufacturer's torque sequence and values precisely, in stages, for even clamping pressure across the head.
Step 5: Final Checks and First Start
Refill with fresh oil and the proper coolant mixture, and bleed the cooling system to remove air pockets, which cause localized overheating. Confirm every hose is clamped, every sensor connected, and every bolt tightened. Reconnect the battery and start the engine. Let it run while you inspect for oil or coolant leaks around the head gasket area, and pressure-test the cooling system to confirm the seal before the engine goes under serious load. After a few heat cycles, a professional tune confirms a modified FA20 is running efficiently and safely. A mechanical fault is fixed mechanically — the tune comes after, and it is mandatory on a modified car.
How Much Does an FA20 Head Gasket Replacement Cost?
DIY Cost
Doing it yourself saves the labor bill, not the parts bill. Expect the cost to start around $1,200 and climb toward $3,000 or more, covering the gasket set, head bolts, fluids, and the other seals that should be replaced along the way. Warped heads add professional resurfacing on top.
Professional Cost
A professional shop typically charges between $1,200 and $3,000, much like the DIY route, with a large portion of the bill being labor. You are paying for a technician's expertise, specialized tools, and the shop's warranty on the work. A reputable shop also inspects for collateral damage — warped heads, worn timing components — and recommends addressing it while the engine is apart.
Labor and Time
Either way, the time is the shock: a head gasket replacement on an FA20 can easily take around 40 hours of skilled labor. The engine has to come out of the car and a significant portion of it disassembled just to reach the heads. This is not a simple weekend project.
When a Mechanic Suggests an Engine Swap Instead
Some mechanics recommend replacing the engine rather than the gaskets, and it is not always an upsell. If the overheating was severe enough to warp the heads or damage internals, machining and additional repairs can approach the price of a replacement engine, and a swap can be the more reliable route with a higher success rate.
That is the honest Crawford route, too, when the damage is deep. Crawford's FA20 DIT short block is rated at 660 hp, built on a brand-new OEM block — no core required or needed — with CrawfordSPEC JE forged pistons, and built and BTO long blocks are available; Crawford-built long blocks ship free. Built engines carry a 1-year, 12,000-mile warranty. Break-in is part of that warranty: oil changes at 500 and 1,500 miles; keep engine speed between 2,000 and 4,500 RPM, varied, with no sustained cruising or full-throttle pulls; do not exceed 80% of target boost until break-in is complete; and the first oil analysis is mandatory. The FA20 long block guide and the FA20 long block builders guide lay out the options. Questions: (855) 677-8243.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Cheap parts and wrong installation. A low-quality gasket on a performance engine is a recipe for a repeat job. Some gaskets are fitted dry, others require sealant — getting that wrong compromises the seal. Fitting the gasket upside down can block oil or coolant passages and cause catastrophic failure. Check the orientation against the service manual before torquing anything.
Ignoring the torque sequence. There is a specific pattern and a multi-stage procedure for a reason: even clamping force across the whole gasket. Skipping it warps the head, creates high and low spots, and forms leaks almost immediately. Use a calibrated torque wrench and the factory sequence. Close enough is not good enough.
Overlooking surface prep. The gasket only seals as well as the surfaces it sits between. Clean both mating surfaces thoroughly with a plastic scraper and appropriate solvent, then verify flatness. A surface beyond tolerance must be machined — no gasket fixes a warped head.
Skipping the final checks. Bleed the cooling system, bring the engine to operating temperature, inspect for leaks around the heads, and pressure-test the cooling system before any serious load.
Related Reading
- Subaru Cylinder Heads: Problems, Costs & Upgrades
- Subaru Cylinder Heads Guide
- Subaru Cylinder Head Guide
- Explore parts
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I keep driving if I think the head gasket is blown? No. Coolant in the oil destroys lubrication and can cause catastrophic failure; combustion gases in the coolant cause overheating and warped heads. Park the car and have it inspected.
Is it worth fixing, or should I get a new engine? If the failure was caught early with no secondary damage, the gasket repair is usually the economical choice. If the engine has very high mileage or severe overheating damage, a new short block is the more reliable long-term answer — especially if more power is planned.
How do I prevent the new gasket from failing? Fix the root cause. Most often that is the cooling system: no leaks, the correct coolant, and an upgraded radiator on a modified car. On a modified vehicle, a professional tune keeps cylinder pressure and heat from compromising the new gasket.
Do the heads absolutely have to be resurfaced? Not always — but flatness must be checked, with a precision straightedge and feeler gauge. If the head is warped beyond the manufacturer's tolerance, resurfacing is not optional.
OEM gasket or aftermarket performance gasket? For a stock vehicle, a high-quality OEM gasket meets the engine's original specifications. With performance parts raising horsepower and cylinder pressure, an MLS performance gasket is the wise investment — it is engineered for the extra stress and heat.
For the full picture — specs, failure points, and upgrade paths — see our FA20 engine guide.
Related reading: Subaru Head Gasket Kit Guide: OEM vs MLS for EJ Builds.