Crawford Performance Air/Oil Separator kit

Subaru AOS vs Catch Can Guide for Turbo Boxer Engines

Both devices do the same job. They separate oil from crankcase vapor before that vapor reaches the intake. The difference is what happens to the oil afterward.

An air oil separator returns the oil to the engine. A catch can stores it in a canister until you drain it. Everything else in this decision follows from that. Crawford's separators are in the Subaru Air Oil Separator collection.

Why blow-by control matters

Under boost, combustion pressure pushes past the rings and pressurizes the crankcase. The PCV system routes that vapor back into the intake so the engine burns it. The vapor carries oil with it.

Oil in the intake does two kinds of harm. It coats the intake tract and the intercooler. And when it reaches the combustion chamber, it lowers the fuel's effective octane, which works against the tune in an engine that lives on boost.

Direct-injected engines have a second problem. Fuel never washes the backs of the intake valves, so deposits from oil vapor build there over time. Port-injected engines get some cleaning effect from the fuel. DI engines do not.

Neither device fixes a worn engine. Both manage vapor from a healthy one. If blow-by suddenly increases, the answer is diagnosing the engine, not fitting a bigger separator.

How a catch can works

A catch can sits in the PCV path. Vapor passes through the can, oil drops out of suspension and collects at the bottom, and the cleaned vapor continues to the intake.

The oil stays in the can. You drain it by hand, on a schedule set by how fast it fills. Fill rate depends on the engine, the boost level, and the weather. Cold weather speeds it up: water vapor condenses in a cold can and mixes with the oil, so a can fills faster in winter than the oil alone would explain.

A full can stops separating. The system only works if the draining actually happens.

Where a catch can makes sense is the track. The can puts the collected fluid in your hand between sessions. A change in volume, color, or consistency is information about the engine. On a car that gets inspected constantly, that is a real advantage, and the draining schedule fits the routine the car already lives on. How a can works and what it needs is covered in the Subaru oil catch can guide.

How an AOS works

An AOS separates the oil and sends it back where it came from. Crawford Performance developed the original closed-loop Subaru AOS: separated oil drains back to the oil pan, and the cleaned vapor continues through the PCV path to the intake. Nothing vents into the engine bay.

The separator is heated by engine coolant. That matters in winter. A cold separator collects condensation the same way a cold catch can does. A heated one keeps moisture in vapor form so it passes through and burns off, instead of condensing and mixing with the oil.

There is no reservoir and nothing to drain. The routine is checking hoses and fittings during normal engine service, the same checks any crankcase ventilation hardware needs. The original walkthrough of the system is Cody's: All about Subaru's Original Air Oil Separator & Why You Need One.

Side by side

AOS Catch can
Oil after separation Returns to the oil pan Stored until drained
Routine upkeep Hose and fitting checks Scheduled draining
Cold weather Heated, no condensation buildup Condensation fills it faster
Track use No drain task between sessions Collected fluid can be inspected
Routing Closed PCV loop Varies by kit

Daily driver

For a car that has to start every morning and may go weeks between hood openings, the AOS is the honest answer. It does not depend on a chore getting done. A catch can on a commuter works only as well as the owner's draining habit, and that habit is the first thing to slip.

If you will genuinely drain a can on schedule, it will do its job. Be honest about which owner you are.

Track car

Both work. The choice is what you want between sessions.

A catch can shows you what came out of the engine. That inspection has diagnostic value on a car pushed hard. An AOS removes a service task and returns the oil to the pan, which suits long sessions and drivers who would rather spend the time on tires, brakes, and data.

High boost raises crankcase vapor flow either way. Sizing and routing matter more than the label on the device. Check hoses, clamps, and fittings before the event and again after the engine cools.

Emissions

Closed-loop routing keeps crankcase vapor in the intake path, the way the factory system works. That does not make every kit legal everywhere. Rules vary by location, model year, and inspection program, and a vent-to-atmosphere setup is a different matter entirely. Confirm the kit's status and your local rules before installing anything on a street-driven Subaru.

Fitment

EJ, FA, and FB engines route hoses differently and mount hardware in different places. Match the kit to the exact car, not just the engine family name.

The Crawford AOS

Crawford V2 and V3 separators are $449.99 MSRP. Baja separators are $349.99 MSRP. One price, no sale framing, and the kit matched to the exact car: shop the AOS collection.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better for a daily driver: AOS or catch can? An AOS, for most owners. It returns separated oil to the engine and asks nothing on a schedule. A catch can works if you will drain it regularly.

Do I need an AOS or a catch can for a tracked Subaru? Either one, sized, routed, and installed correctly. Pick the can if you want to inspect collected fluid between sessions. Pick the AOS if you want the oil returned and one less task.

What are the maintenance requirements for each? A catch can needs scheduled inspection and draining, more often in cold weather. An AOS needs no draining. Both need periodic checks for loose hoses, leaks, and restrictions.

Does installing an AOS affect emissions compliance? It can, if the installation changes required crankcase ventilation equipment or vents vapor to the atmosphere. Closed-loop routing keeps vapor in the intake path, but that guarantees nothing. Check local rules before installing on a street car.

Is an AOS worth the extra cost over a catch can? It costs more up front and asks less afterward. If your habit is to fit a part and service it with the engine, the AOS earns its price. If you inspect the car constantly anyway, a can does the separation job for less.

The short version

A catch can is a simple device that works when its owner does. An AOS costs more and takes the owner out of the equation. Daily drivers and cold climates favor the AOS. Track cars can justify either, and the inspection argument for the can is a fair one.

Supporting parts for the install are in the WRX and STI performance parts and BRZ performance parts collections. Questions about fitment for a specific car: (855) 677-8243.

Back to blog