Crawford Dual Chamber AOS Review: Is It Worth It?
Share
This is Crawford's own product, so this is not an independent test and there are no test results to report. What follows are the design facts: how the dual chamber AOS is built, how it separates oil, what installation involves, and who it is worth buying for. Judge it on the design.
What an air oil separator does
Every engine produces blow-by: combustion gases and unburnt fuel that slip past the piston rings into the crankcase, carrying oil vapor with them. Turbocharged engines produce more of it. The factory system routes those gases back into the intake to be re-burned.
That is the problem. The oil vapor coats the intake manifold, the intercooler, and the valves. It restricts airflow as it builds up. Worse, oil mixed into the incoming air and fuel lowers the effective octane of the charge. Lower octane means a higher risk of detonation — engine knock — which can damage internal components.
An air oil separator intercepts the blow-by before it reaches the intake. It separates the oil from the air, sends clean air back into the engine, and returns the separated oil to the oil pan, where it belongs.
Crawford developed the original closed-loop Subaru AOS. The dual chamber unit is built for the boxer engine's specific blow-by problem, and it matters most on cars that get driven hard. Under high G-forces and heavy acceleration, an engine produces significantly more blow-by. That is when the intake needs protecting.
AOS vs. catch can
A catch can is a reservoir. Oil vapor condenses inside it and stays there until you empty it by hand. Forget, and the can overflows and sends the collected oil back into the engine — the exact thing you installed it to prevent.
An AOS is a closed-loop system. It separates the oil and drains it back into the engine automatically. There is nothing to empty and nothing to check. That difference is the whole argument, and it is covered in full in AOS vs. catch can.
The dual chamber design
The Crawford AOS is machined from aluminum. It is lighter than competitors' heavy cast designs, and the cast weight buys nothing. It is made in the USA with USA components. Competitors make theirs in China.
Inside, separation happens in two stages. The first chamber slows the air charge coming from the crankcase, which lets the heavier oil droplets fall out of suspension. The air then moves to a second chamber for a final round of separation. Only cleaned air re-enters the intake.
Two chambers are not a styling choice. One pass leaves oil behind. The second pass is there to catch what the first one missed.
The built-in heater
Condensation is the failure point of oil separation in cold weather. Water vapor mixes with oil vapor and forms a thick, milky sludge that can clog lines and stop a separator from working.
The Crawford AOS uses engine coolant to heat the whole unit. The heater keeps condensation from forming that sludge, so the system works the same on a cold start as it does on a hot track day, in any climate.
Automatic oil drain
Separated oil does not sit in the unit. It routes directly back into the engine's oil pan. There are no cans to check, no fluid levels to watch, and no drain interval to remember. Install it and the system maintains itself.
What it prevents
Carbon buildup. Blow-by that reaches the intake coats the intercooler, manifold, and valves. The AOS stops the oil before it gets there, so the intake tract stays clean and airflow stays unrestricted.
Oil consumption and knock. Oil vapor that enters the combustion chamber gets burned with the air-fuel mixture. That consumes oil and lowers the fuel's effective octane at the same time. Keeping oil out of the intake addresses both: less oil burned, and less detonation risk.
Maintenance. A catch can adds a chore. This system adds none.
Installation
Most owners with basic mechanical skills can install the AOS in about one to two hours with standard hand tools. The kit includes the hoses, clamps, and brackets needed. There is more tubing to manage than with a simple catch can, because the built-in heater connects to the engine's coolant lines. That is the trade for maintenance-free operation.
Two details decide whether the system works:
- Hose routing. The hose running from the AOS back to the PCV valve must keep a continuous downward slope. Gravity returns the separated oil to the crankcase. A low spot or a U in the line lets oil pool instead of draining. Do not pinch hoses, especially with a large top-mount intercooler taking up engine bay space.
- Mounting. Some 2010–2012 models have a large plastic intake manifold that makes the bracket mounting point tight. Work around it rather than forcing the routing.
Two common oversights: forgetting to plug the radiator fans back in after making room, and failing to bleed air from the coolant system afterward. Take your time and check both. The step-by-step is in the Subaru AOS installation guide.
If you are not comfortable working on the car, have a qualified shop do the install. Correct routing matters more than who turns the wrench.
Fitment
The Crawford AOS covers a broad range of Subarus from 2002 to the present — WRX, STI, Crosstrek, Forester, and others — including newer vehicles like the 5th generation Outback and specific 4th generation models. Fitment varies by model, year, and trim, and small changes between model years can affect installation. Verify compatibility for your exact car before ordering.
One check tells you whether your engine needs one: pull the PCV tube. If the inside is coated in oil, the engine is producing blow-by that is reaching the intake. Fitment for a specific application, such as the 2015 Subaru WRX air oil separator, is listed in the AOS collection.
One compliance fact: Crawford's AOS does not carry a CARB executive order. Check the EO status for your application before you buy.
Is it worth it?
For track days and autocross: yes. High G-forces and aggressive acceleration slosh the oil and increase blow-by at exactly the moment the engine is under the most load. Separation has to keep working under those conditions. That is what the dual chamber design and the heater are for. If the car is part of a broader build, the AOS belongs in the plan with the rest of the WRX upgrades.
For daily driving: yes, as prevention. A stock, daily-driven turbocharged Subaru still produces blow-by, and over thousands of miles the oil still coats the intake and still raises knock risk. An AOS is cheaper than the engine damage it prevents. It is a preventative part, installed before the deposits form.
When you might not need one: if the car is used for casual commuting and never driven hard, the benefit is small. An AOS is also not a fix for a pre-existing oil consumption problem. It manages blow-by; it does not repair an engine that is already burning oil for another reason.
Price and where to buy
The Crawford Dual Chamber AOS — the V3 — is $449.99 MSRP — every V3 application, one price, one price per fitment, labeled MSRP. Buy from Crawford Performance directly to get the genuine, current version of the part and the correct kit for your car. Counterfeit and superseded versions are a real risk through unknown sellers.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need one on a stock daily driver? A stock turbocharged Subaru produces blow-by from the first mile. The AOS is prevention: it keeps the intake clean and keeps oil out of the fuel charge, which protects performance and reliability over the life of the engine.
Why does it cost more than a catch can? A catch can is a container you empty by hand. The Crawford AOS is a complete, closed-loop system: two chambers of separation, a coolant heater that prevents sludge, and an automatic drain back to the oil pan. You are paying for the system, not the can.
What happens without one? Blow-by goes straight into the intake. Oil coats the intercooler, manifold, and valves, restricts airflow, gets burned as oil consumption, and lowers the effective octane of the charge — which raises the risk of detonation.
What makes the Crawford design different? Two things: the dual chamber separation system and the integrated coolant heater. Crawford developed the original closed-loop Subaru AOS, and the design is purpose-built for the boxer engine rather than adapted from a generic can.
Related reading
Questions about fitment for your car: (855) 677-8243.